
SET Announcements
21 March 2000
AUDITED YEARLY F/S(1999)
Auditors' Report
To the Shareholders of CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
I have audited the consolidated balance sheets of CH. Karnchang Public Company
Limited, subsidiaries and joint ventures as at December 31, 1999 and 1998, and the related consolidated
statements of income, changes in shareholders' equity and retained earnings, and consolidated statements
of cash flows for the years then ended and the financial statements of CH. Karnchang Public Co.,Ltd. for
the same years then ended. The company's management are responsible for the correctness and
completeness of information presented in these financial statements. My responsibility is to express an
opinion on these financial statements based on my audit.
Except as discussed in the fourth and fifth paragraphs, I conducted my audits in
accordance with generally accepted auditing standards. Those standards require that I plan and perform
the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material
misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and
disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and
significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall financial statements
presentation. I believe that my audit provides a reasonable basis for my opinion.
In 1998, the parent company did not recorded the allowance for doubtful account for
accounts receivable from the related joint venture, which are overdue over 1 year in the approximated
amount of Baht 324.94 million, therefore I express the qualified opinion to the financial statements in
1998 according to the report dated February 15, 1999. However, the parent company had adjusted the
allowance for doubtful debt of the said transaction in the financial statements of 1999.
As discussed in Note 16 to the financial statements. The joint venture which the
company has 35% of profit sharing, whose project will be completed in 2000, had recorded the allowance
for impairment of fixed assets which are expected to be sold at price lower than net book value in the
approximated amount, by the proportion of profit sharing, of Baht 49 million. The joint venture can not
estimated allowance for impairment of fixed assets for the remaining amount as at December 31, 1999 in
the financial statements in the approximated amount of Baht 375.9 million.
As discussed in Note 16 to the financial statements, I was unable to apply any audit
procedure to obtain the sufficient evidences for the cost of land of a subsidiary which the company had
invested in 1999, land was recorded at cost in the approximated amount of Baht 92.3 million and the
appraisal value from Land Department is in the approximated amount of Baht 53.6 million. In addition, at
present this subsidiary produces and sells most of the products to the joint venture whose project is going
to finish as mentioned in the fourth paragraph and the subsidiary can not estimate the allowance for
impairment of other fixed assets in the consolidated statement as at December 31, 1999 in the
approximated amount of Baht 172.12 million.
In my opinion, except for the effects on the 1999 financial statements of such
adjustments, if any, as might have been determined to be necessary had I been able to apply adequate
procedures to the matter discussed in the fourth and fifth paragraph and except for the effects on the
financial statements of 1998 of the matter discussed in the third paragraph, the consolidated financial
statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of CH. Karnchang Public Co.,Ltd.,
subsidiaries and joint ventures as at December 31, 1999 and 1998, and the results of their operations and
cash flows for the years then ended and of CH. Karnchang Public Co.,Ltd., in conformity with generally
accepted accounting principles .
As discusses in Note 5 to the financial statements. Ch. Karnchang Public Company
Limited, subsidiaries and joint ventures had changed their accounting policy for deferred charges in 1999.
I draw attention to Note 1 to the financial statements. The operations of CH. Karnchang
Public Company Limited, subsidiaries and joint ventures may continue to be influenced by the economic
conditions in Thailand and the Asia Pacific Region in general.
Supot Singhasaneh
Certified Public Accountant
Registrative number 2826
KPMG Audit (Thailand) Limited
Bangkok, February 18, 2000
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
BALANCE SHEETS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
Amounts : Baht Consolidated CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
ASSETS 1999 1998 1999 1998
RESTATED RESTATED
CURRENT ASSETS
Cash on hand and at banks (Note 6) 4,055,912,090 5,059,682,837 1,421,787,831 1,942,289,674
Short - term investments (Note 7) 202,420,442 212,281,559 601,711 574,211
Investment in marketable securities (Note 4) 977,125 7,958,624 977,125 7,958,625
Accounts receivable - net (Note 8) 945,051,382 2,296,581,355 658,134,638 1,312,413,505
Accounts receivable and loan to subsidiary,
related companies and joint ventures 572,391,979 602,776,253 692,393,729 812,872,737
Construction contract in progress - net (Note 9) 2,367,462,505 3,767,313,466 - 347,697,662
Inventories,supplies for construction and
construction in progress - net (Notes 4 and 10) 68,012,247 404,731,246 21,162,069 20,422,485
Advance payment to subcontractors - net (Note 11) 88,569,722 188,227,375 24,856,451 47,045,174
Advance payment 77,645,060 15,212,696 - -
Accrued interest income 38,122,194 - 52,525,789 18,482,068
Accrued income 14,263,923 2,361,658 14,263,923 30,785,674
Refundable input tax - net (Note 12) 125,313,864 189,691,373 - -
Unbilled input tax 73,462,043 92,932,828 13,069,962 11,817,895
Other current assets (Note 13) 39,712,304 154,496,397 12,488,276 12,772,388
Total Current Assets 8,669,316,880 12,994,247,667 2,912,261,504 4,565,132,098
Notes receivable-finance companies (Note 14) - 42,117,187 - -
Investments in subsidiary companies and
joint ventures (Notes 4 and 15) - - 1,126,290,100 1,290,988,189
Investments in associated related and other
companies (Notes 4 and 15) 2,163,530,776 2,245,623,440 1,984,614,688 2,101,248,400
Property, plant and equipment-net (Notes 4 and 16) 1,483,364,505 2,095,713,596 439,356,814 528,141,477
Investment on land (Note 17) 155,779,735 202,731,721 132,765,798 174,600,000
Advance payment for project (Note 18) 128,265,484 69,350,012 - -
Withhoding tax (Note 19) 281,521,358 288,520,052 161,919,435 161,919,435
Other assets 16,672,291 371,371,185 6,483,160 7,082,717
Total Assets 12,898,451,029 18,309,674,860 6,763,691,499 8,829,112,316
See notes to financial statements
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
BALANCE SHEETS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
Amounts : Baht Consolidated CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY 1999 1998 1999 1998
RESTATED RESTATED
CURRENT LIABILITIES
Bank overdrafts and loans from banks (Note 20) 3,079,640,207 3,104,715,162 882,382,327 1,014,490,811
Notes payable - finance institute 200,000,000 100,000,000 200,000,000 100,000,000
Accounts and notes payable 781,404,895 1,721,967,086 480,883,096 853,572,479
Current portion of long-term liabilities (Notes 21 and 22) 3,630,064,225 3,902,697,982 - 898,362,500
Accounts payable and loans from
related companies and joint ventures 1,063,319,500 1,352,668,406 30,417,640 42,079,072
Advance received from contractor and deferred
construction revenue (Note 9) 1,414,383,503 1,466,374,702 497,713,138 183,625,834
Retentions for construction 195,374,094 239,779,492 93,343,614 81,714,405
Allowance loss from constrution (Note 9) 134,127,269 - - -
Accrued interest expense 42,696,335 99,718,536 13,223,981 60,023,448
Accrued income tax 30,761,194 8,338,908 - -
Accrued expense 25,002,107 - 28,125,315 8,338,908
Unbilled out put tax 117,473,581 195,665,071 93,143,602 127,399,624
Other current liabilities 90,055,093 106,978,961 14,213,843 30,076,713
Total Current Liabilities 10,804,302,003 12,298,904,306 2,333,446,556 3,399,683,794
Long - term loans from related companies 165,541,273 - - -
Liabilities under discounted notes receivable (Note 21) - 1,082,749,500 - -
Long-term loans (Note 22) 262,118,058 542,395,758 240,000,000 200,000,000
Allowance loss for doubful account
from related companies (Note 8) 272,302,862 - - -
Other liabilities (Note 15) - - 3,056,839,745 998,792,098
Total Liabilities 11,504,264,196 13,924,049,564 5,630,286,301 4,598,475,892
MINORITY INTEREST IN SUBSIDIARY COMPANIES 240,840,257 154,988,872 - -
SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
Share capital
Authorized 105,000,000 ordinary shares, Baht 10 par value 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000
Issued and fully paid 105,000,000 ordinary shares,
Baht 10 par value 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000
Premium on share 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000
Retained earnings
Appropriated to legal reserve 88,442,063 88,442,063 82,942,063 82,942,063
Unappropriated (2,238,447,317) 656,194,361 (2,232,947,317) 661,694,361
Unrealized loss on change in investment value (Note 15) (182,648,170) - (202,589,548) -
Total Shareholders' Equity 1,153,346,576 4,230,636,424 1,133,405,198 4,230,636,424
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity 12,898,451,029 18,309,674,860 6,763,691,499 8,829,112,316
See notes to financial statements
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
STATEMENTS OF INCOME
FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
Consolidated CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
Amounts : Baht 1999 1998 1999 1998
RESTATED RESTATED
REVENUES
Construction activities income (Note 23) 7,915,837,725 13,223,501,604 2,318,368,474 3,275,811,717
Sale of construction material 490,575,896 392,919,743 539,991,456 597,891,593
Management income 73,286,827 84,804,216 101,485,519 147,853,701
Rental income 46,417,753 81,043,964 79,363,297 120,993,767
Transportation income 38,554,936 55,422,815 41,108,204 59,146,317
Interest income 141,811,411 344,571,568 77,773,402 112,182,183
Gain from sale of investment (Note 15) - 169,070,874 - 152,570,874
Gain on exchange rate (Note 24 ) - 286,472,245 6,677,217 -
Share of net profit (loss) by equity method (77,743,732) (38,007,094) (2,156,761,405) 119,660,207
Good will written off (Notes 4 and 15) 11,535,685 - - -
Other incomes 45,848,312 61,654,950 52,930,915 46,860,223
Total Revenues 8,686,124,813 14,661,454,885 1,060,937,079 4,632,970,582
EXPENSES
Cost of construction activities and
sale constrution material 8,500,971,857 12,159,146,452 2,361,679,844 3,526,988,039
Administrative expenses 485,947,992 681,867,388 249,946,109 285,351,012
Interest expenses 831,822,728 1,150,681,875 224,418,528 423,428,362
Directors' remuneration 7,300,000 7,822,250 7,300,000 7,822,250
Allowance for doubtful accounts (Notes 2,4 and 8) 855,766,773 8,836,571 729,180,098 7,588,765
Allowance for loss form constrution contracts (Note 9) 160,889,826 - - -
Other expenses
Loss from impairment of investment (Note 15) 65,007,431 27,291,095 63,291,431 27,291,095
Loss from impairment of property , plant
and equipment-net (Note 16) 213,336,221 27,716,002 73,859,768 12,777,069
Loss from impairment of investment in land (Note 17) 46,112,953 - 41,834,203 -
Other expenses 187,715,037 128,662,297 125,327,340 127,399,274
Total Expenses 11,354,870,818 14,192,023,930 3,876,837,321 4,418,645,866
Profit (loss) before income tax (2,668,746,005) 469,430,955 (2,815,900,242) 214,324,716
Income tax 228,607,733 235,388,705 78,741,436 3,083,137
Net profit (loss) from operation (2,897,353,738) 234,042,250 (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579
Plus (less) Minority interest in net (profit) loss 2,712,060 (22,800,671) - -
Net profit (loss) (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579 (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579
Net profit (loss) per share (Baht) (Note 4 ) (27.57) 2.01 (27.57) 2.01
See notes to financial statements
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
Consolidated CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
Amounts : Baht 1999 1998 1999 1998
RESTATED RESTATED
ORDINARY SHARE CAPITAL
Beginning balance 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000
Increase during year - - - -
Decrease during year - - - -
Ending balance 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000 1,050,000,000
PREMIUM ON SHARE CAPITAL
Beginning balance 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000
Increase during year - - - -
Decrease during year - - - -
Ending balance 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000 2,436,000,000
APPROPRIATED RETAINED EARNINGS
Beginning balance 88,442,063 78,046,679 82,942,063 72,546,679
Increase during year - 10,395,384 - 10,395,384
Decrease during year - - - -
Ending balance 88,442,063 88,442,063 82,942,063 82,942,063
UNAPPROPRIATED RETAINED EARNINGS (DEFICIT)
Beginning balance 818,018,761 620,506,455 823,518,761 626,006,455
Accumulative effect resulting from change in accounting
policy of deferred expenses (Note 5 ) (63,396,504) (104,737,486) (63,396,504) (104,737,486)
Accumulative effect resulting from change in accounting
for investment (Note 5 ) (98,427,896) (60,420,803) (98,427,896) (60,420,803)
Beginning balance as restated 656,194,361 455,348,166 661,694,361 460,848,166
Increase during the year - Net profit (loss) (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579 (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579
Decrease during the year - Transfer to legal reserve (Note 25 ) - (10,395,384) - (10,395,384)
- Payment of dividend (Note 25 ) - - - -
Ending balance (2,238,447,317) 656,194,361 (2,232,947,317) 661,694,361
UNREALIZED LOSS ON CHANGE INVESTMENT VALUE
Beginning balance - - - -
Increase during year (Note 15 ) (182,648,170) - (202,589,548) -
Decrease during year - - - -
Ending balance (182,648,170) - (202,589,548) -
Total Shareholders' Equity 1,153,346,576 4,230,636,424 1,133,405,198 4,230,636,424
See notes to financial statements
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
STATEMENTS OF RETAINED EARNING (DEFICIT)
FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
Consolidated CH. Karnchang Public Co., Ltd.
Amounts : Baht 1999 1998 1999 1998
RESTATED RESTATED
Unappropriated retained earnings
Retained earnings at beginning of the year 818,018,761 620,506,455 823,518,761 626,006,455
Less Accumulative effect resulting from change in accounting
policy of deferred expenses (Note 5 ) (63,396,504) (104,737,486) (63,396,504) (104,737,486)
Accumulative effect resulting from change in accounting
for of investment (Note 5 ) (98,427,896) (60,420,803) (98,427,896) (60,420,803)
Less Appropriated net profit of prior year
Dividend (Note 25 ) - - - -
Beginning balance as restated 656,194,361 455,348,166 661,694,361 460,848,166
Increase during the year - Net profit (loss) (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579 (2,894,641,678) 211,241,579
Less legal reserve (Note 25 ) - (10,395,384) - (10,395,384)
Unappropriated retained earnings (deficit) at end of the year (2,238,447,317) 656,194,361 (2,232,947,317) 661,694,361
Appropriated retained earnings 88,442,063 78,046,679 82,942,063 72,546,679
legal reserve (Note 25 ) - 10,395,384 - 10,395,384
Total appropriated retained earnings 88,442,063 88,442,063 82,942,063 82,942,063
Total retained earnings (deficit) (2,150,005,254) 744,636,424 (2,150,005,254) 744,636,424
See notes to financial statements
CH. KARNCHANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED, SUBSIDIARIES AND JOINT VENTURES
STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS
FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1999 AND 1998
(more)