SET Announcements
19 April 2007
1) Opinion of Independent Financial Advisor Concerning
2.3 Financial performances
2.3.1 Summary of financial status and the Company's performances
audited by Ernst & Young as at 31st December 2004 and 2006
(Unit : Baht
Million)
Consolidated Audited
Financial Statements 31st Dec. 04 31st Dec. 05 31st Dec.
06
Current assets
Cash and cash equivalents 4,979.56 1,542.69 3,033.26
Trade account receivables, unrelated parties - net
4,939.33 5,045.96 5,489.45
Other current assets 4,533.94 10,619.76 10,120.03
Total current assets 14,452.83 17,208.41 18,642.72
Non-current assets
Investments in associated companies 1,046.51 4,014.01 4,674.35
Investment in related and other companies
3,475.72 2,611.18 2,967.35
Other non-current assets 5,884.48 5,989.33 4,029.48
Total non-current assets 10,406.71 12,614.52 11,671.18
Total assets 24,859.54 29,822.93 30,313.91
Current liabilities
Bank overdrafts and short-term loans 1,877.16 5,510.20 3,822.85
Current portion of long-term loans 730.97 934.93 3,897.04
Other current liabilities 9,455.99 9,664.85 11,087.73
Total current liabilities 12,064.12 16,109.98 18,807.62
Non-current liabilities
Long-term loans, net of current portion
4,663.96 2,430.55 450.00
Debentures, net of current portion 3,000.00 6,000.00 5,800.00
Non-current liabilities 336.40 353.44 454.19
Total non-current liabilities 8,000.36 8,783.99 6,704.19
Total liabilities 20,064.48 24,893.97 25,511.81
Registered capital 1,312.50 1,450.00 1,450.00
Paid-up capital 1,058.68 1,081.16 1,247.19
Retained earning (loss) 336.86 913.98 (688.28)
Total shareholders' equity 4,795.06 4,928.95 4,802.09
Total liabilities and shareholders' equity
24,859.54 29,822.93 30,313.91
Total revenues 7,772.79 14,954.97 21,605.29
Total expenses 6,925.07 13,239.73 21,439.70
Interest expenses 393.81 652.25 980.55
Net profit (loss) 204.47 684.17 (1,212.84)
Net profit (loss) per share (Baht) 0.19 0.63 (1.08)
Book value per share (Baht) 4.53 4.56 3.85
Notes : Par value at Baht 1 per share
As at 31st December 2006, the CK group had total assets of Baht 30,314
million (major assets includes cash and cash equivalents, trade account
receivables (non-related parties), construction contracts in progress),
total liabilities of Baht 25,512 million (including long-term loans to
associated companies and accrued interest, investment in associated,
related and other companies), and shareholders' equity of Baht 4,802
million, compared with Baht 29,823 million, Baht 24,894 million, and Baht
4,929 million, respectively as at 31st December 2005.
The group earned income from three core businesses, construction, building
material distribution, and project management. As at 31st December 31
2006, income from these three businesses made up 87.57%, 0.90% and 0.44%
respectively of total revenues, with the rest 11.09% earned from other
income.
CK's consolidated revenues as at 31st December 2006 were Baht 21,605
million, compared with Baht 14,955 million in the same period of 2005. The
group sustained a net loss of Baht 1,213 million, compared with a net
profit earned in the corresponding period of 2005 of Baht 685 million,
caused chiefly by a drastic plunge in the Company's profit from 2005 by
Baht 1,897 million or 277.28%. On the expenses side, there were allowances
for doubtful accounts on receivables from indemnity for incremental
expenses and loss sharing from JV BBCD, which was a consequence of the
Supreme Court's ruling to withhold the arbitrator's judgement for the
Expressway and Rapid Transit Authority of Thailand (ETA) to make payment to
JV BBCD. However, such court ruling would not prejudice JV's legitimate
right to claims for the incremental expenses of Baht 6,040 million plus
interest of 7.50% p.a.
The group's total revenues of Baht 21,605 million in 2006 grew tremendously
by 44.46% from Baht 14,955 million in 2005, thanks to progress on
construction with soaring income from construction service, notably from
the Nam Ngum 2 dam project in Laos PDR, the ETA's Bang Phli - Suksawat
(Bang Phli - Bang Khunthian) expressway project, the water discharge tunnel
from Bung Makkasan to the Chao Phraya River project of Bangkok Metropolitan
Administration, and the Ground Improvement for the 1st Midfield Satellite
Aprons & 3rd Runway Project of Bangkok Airport Co., Ltd. The said revenue
growth was also ascribed to gains from sale of short-term investments in
ordinary shares of TTW to Mitsui Water Holding (Thailand) Co., Ltd. and
BECL, as well as to income from reversal of accrued interest payable under
joint agreement among JV BBCD members to waive the entire interest payable
on loans from JV members. The construction service revenues came from
customers in the government and private sectors, in a ratio of 70 : 30. As
at 31st December 2006, the Company had projects in pipeline with revenues
to be recognized in the future totaling Baht 29,597 million; a project
under contract signing for the toll system and traffic safety control
system of Bang Phli - Bang Khunthian Expressway, Suksawat - Bang Khunthian
Section, with a construction value plus VAT of around Baht 2,619 million;
and the water filtration plant expansion of PTW with a construction value
plus VAT of some Baht 800 million.
2.3.2 Key financial ratios
Consolidated financial statements Audited
31st Dec. 04 31st Dec. 05 31st Dec. 06
Liquidity ratios:
Current ratio (times) 1.20 1.07 0.99
Quick ratio (times) 0.82 0.26 0.17
Receivables turnover (times) 2.53 5.07 3.13
Collection period (days) 143 72 116
Inventory turnover period (times) 68.88 44.53 89.60
Average sale period (days) 6 9 5
Payment period (days) 109 228 204
Account payable turnover (times) 3.32 1.58 1.77
Cash cycle (days) 40 (149) (85)
Profitability ratios:
Gross profit margin (%) 20.44 13.34 9.49
Net margin (%) 2.63 4.57 (5.61)
Return on equity (%) 4.49 14.07 (25.28)
Efficiency ratios:
Return on assets (%) 1.02 2.50 (4.40)
Assets turnover (times) 0.39 0.55 0.78
Financial ratios:
Debt to equity ratio (times) 4.18 5.05 5.31
Net debt to equity ratio (times) 1.11 2.28 1.85
Interest coverage (times) 2.15 (2.53) 1.39
Contingent liabilities coverage ratio (times)
(1.50) (0.87) 0.00
Liquidity
As regards CK group's liquidity in 2006, its net cash flow as shown in the
consolidated financial statements surged by Baht 1,493 million. Such
increase stemmed from cash flow provided from investing activity of Baht
1,704 million from sale of short-term investments (TTW ordinary shares) and
net cash flow provided from financing activity of Baht 2,554 million (issue
of debentures worth Baht 2,000 million and new ordinary shares of Baht
1,442 million), with cash flow used in operating activity of Baht 2,751
million. However, the considerable project progress caused trade
receivables from projects under construction to scale up. Owing to this,
coupled with return to employers of advance from employers and installment
construction payments, as well as impacts from foreign exchange on cash and
cash equivalents, the Company's cash flow went down, with cash and cash
equivalents as of end-2006 standing at Baht 3,033 million.
Overall, the group's financial status in 2006 weakened from 2005, with
liquidity ratio falling from 1.07 to just 0.99 and quick ratio from 0.26 to
0.17. Debt to equity ratio rose from 5.05 to 5.31 due to additional
debenture issued. Revenue collection period was 116 days, compared with
only 72 days in 2005, resulting from delayed government budget disbursement
in the wake of political turmoil. However, the Company could better manage
the net debt to equity ratio under the debenture conditions, as evident
from a drop in this ratio. Such debt was interest-bearing, consisting of
overdraft loans, payables under hire-purchase contracts due within one
year, long-term loans due within one year, debentures due within one year,
payables and loans from related businesses, payables under hire-purchase
contracts net of amount due within one year, long-term borrowings net of
amount due within one year, debentures net of amount due within one year,
deducted by cash and cash equivalent, encumbered deposits at banks,
short-term investments, and trade receivables from public agencies or state
enterprises under construction contracts bearing interest and with
performance acceptance letters already issued by those agencies, i.e.
receivables from the ETA's Bang Phli - Suksawat (Bang Phli - Bang
Khunthian) expressway project, which decreased in 2006. The Company had
cash available from new share issue of Baht 1,442 million, which helped to
push cash and shareholders' equity up. In view of the Supreme Court's
ruling to withhold the arbitrator's judgement for ETA to make payment to JV
BBCD, with such court ruling not prejudicing JV's legitimate right to
claims for the incremental expenses of Baht 6,040 billion plus interest of
7.50% p.a., the Company must in accounting terms state an allowance for
doubtful accounts on receivables from indemnity for incremental expenses in
the consolidated financial statements, thereby leading the shareholders'
equity to decrease. According to the joint agreement among JV BBCD members
to waive the entire interest payable on loans from JV members, the Company
recorded reversal of accrued interest payable of Baht 443 million in the
revenues item of the income statement under the consolidated financial
statements and income from deferred accrued interest receivable of Baht 13
million as expense in the income statement under the consolidated financial
statements, thereby leading the shareholders' equity to increase. In 2006,
the net debt to equity ratio stood at 1.85, down from 2.28 in 2005.
2.4 Shareholdings
The major shareholders of the Company as shown in share register book as at
7th April 2006, which was the latest book closure date are as follows:
NameNo. of shares % of holding
1. Trivisvavet Group
1.1 Mr. Tavorn Trivisvavet 16,481,000 1.51
1.2 Mr. Plew Trivisvavet 16,498,000 1.52
1.3 Mr. Kamthorn Trivisvavet 651,000 0.06
1.4 Mr. Prasert Trivisvavet 2,348,000 0.22
1.5 Mahasiri Siam Co., Ltd. 1/ 240,667,000 22.10
1.6 CH. Karnchang Holding Co., Ltd.1/ 125,589,500 11.53
1.7 CK. Office Tower Co., Ltd. 2/ 75,000,000 6.89
1.8 Bang Pa-in Land Development Co., Ltd.3/ 18,935,000 1.74
Total 496,169,500 45.57
2. TMB Bank Plc. 93,268,300 8.56
3. Mrs. Pranee Thongkittikul 63,214,300 5.80
4. Mr. Charnnarong Vongsrinil 27,000,000 2.48
5. Thai NVDR Co., Ltd. 24,836,700 2.28
6. Morgan Stanley & Co International Limited
16,950,000 1.56
7. Mr. Chitrarun Anubhantanand 13,651,500 1.25
8. State Street Bank and Trust Company for Australia
12,000,000 1.10
9. Chase C.S. Central Nominees Limited19 11,424,500 1.05
10. HSBC (Singapore) Nominees Pte Ltd. 9,114,800 0.84
Total 767,629,600 70.49
Notes:1/ All directors of these companies are Trivisvavet Group.
2/ Trivisvavet Group holds 62.50 of total shares, the others are
minority shareholders.
3/ Trivisvavet Group holds 41.66 of total shares, the others are
minority shareholders.
2.5 The Board of Directors
The Board of Directors of CK as at 2nd April 2007 is as follows:
Name Position
1. Mr. Plew Trivisvavet Chairman of the Executive Board and President
2. Mr. Narong Sangsuriya Director
3. Mrs. Saikasem Trivisvavet Director
4. Mr. Ratn Santaannop Director
5. Mr. Prasert Marittanaporn Director
6. Dr. Sombat Kitjalaksana Director
7. Mr. Anukool Tuntimas Director
8. Mr. Aswin KongsiriIndependent Director
9. Mr. Vitoon Tejatussanasoontorn Chairman of Audit Committee
10. Mr. Don Pramudwinai Audit Committee
11. Mr. Thawansak Sukhawun Audit Committee
2.6 Profile of Thai Tap Water Plc.
2.6.1 Background
TTW was established on 11th September 2000 (as a joint venture between CK
and Thames Water Group in proportion of 50 : 50) with a registration number
0107549000114 to produce and distribute tap water to the PWA in the
areas of Nakhon Pathom Province and Samut Sakhon Province, through the
Company's Concession Agreement with PWA, whereby the Company is the owner
of the tap water production and distribution systems, and the title to the
tap water production and distribution systems shall not be required to be
transferred to PWA, with the concession period of 30 years from 21st July
2004 to 21st July 2034.
2.6.2 Financial performances
Summary of financial status and TTW's performances audited by Ernst & Young
as at 31st December 2004 and 2006:
(Unit : Baht Million)
Consolidated Audited
Financial Statements 31st Dec. 04 31st Dec. 05 31st Dec. 06
Total current assets 459.81 820.44 1306.61
Total non-current assets 9753.94 9540.52 9375.29
Total assets 10213.75 10360.96 10681.95
Total liabilities 7095.97 7013.15 6792.09
Registered and paid-up capital 3000.00 3000.00 3250.00
Total shareholders' equity 3117.78 3347.82 3889.86
Total liabilities and shareholders' equity
10213.75 10360.96 10681.95
Total revenues 889.91 1360.25 1722.19
Total expenses 276.16 680.32 610.77
Interest expenses 151.18 344.90 437.02
Net profit (loss) 432.57 335.04 674.02
Net profit (loss) per share (Baht) 14.56 11.17 0.21
Book value per share (Baht) 88.81 111.59 1.20
Notes : TTW has changed par value from Baht 100 to Baht 1 per share on 6th
July 2006.
2.6.3 Shareholdings
The shareholders of TTW as at 23rd March 2007 are as follows:
Name No. of shares % of holding
1. CH. Karnchang Plc. 1,549,839,400 47.69
2. Mitsui Water Holdings (Thailand) Limited 1,137,500,000 35.00
3. Bangkok Expressway Plc. 406,250,000 12.50
4. Bangkok Bank Plc. 81,410,000 2.50
5. TMB Bank Plc. 75,000,000 2.30
6. Dr. Sombat Kitjalaksana 100 0.00
7. Mr. Narong Sangsuriya 100 0.00
8. Mr. Prasert Marittanaporn 100 0.00
9. Mr. Sompodh Sripom 100 0.00
10. Mr. Samai Paiboon 100 0.00
11. Ms. Pansakun Panphrom 96 0.00
12. Mr. Nopadol Intralib 1 0.00
13. Mrs. Sunantha Khemaprapa 1 0.00
14. Mr. Propoj Jirasathitpornpong 1 0.00
15. Sawitree Treenawarut 1 0.00
Total 3,250,000,000 100.00
2.6.4 The Board of Directors
The Board of Directors of TTW as at 2nd February 2007 is as follows:
Name Position
1. Mr. Plew Trivisvavet Chairman
2. Mr. Narong Sangsuriya Director
3. Mr. Prasert Marittanaporn Director
4. Dr. Sombat Kitjalaksana Director
5. Mr. Sompodh Sripom Director
6. Mr. Yoshio Kometani Director
7. Mr. Tomoaki Matsumoto Director
8. Mr. Techathip Sangsingkeo Director
9. Mr. Phairuch Mekarporn Director
10. Mr. Somnuk Chaidejsuriya Director
11. Mr. Suvich Pungcharoen Director
3. Profile of company to be disposed
3.1 Background and significant development
Pathum Thani Tap Water Co., Ltd., formerly PCKT (Thailand) Co., Ltd., was
established on 29th May 1995 with a registration number 0105538063801 to
produce and distribute tap water and operate relevant businesses, including
repair and maintenance of the tap water production and distribution system
under the concession awarded by the Provincial Waterworks Authority. PTW
has a subsidiary, BJT Water Co., Ltd. ("BJT").
PTW current registered capital is Baht 2,752 million, of which divided into
27,520,000 shares at Baht 100 par value per share. The Company's Head
Office located at 43 Moo 3 Chiangrak Noi-Bangsai Road, Tambol Baan Pathum,
Amphur Samkhok, Pathumthani
Major changes and the Company's significant development
29th May 1995 PTW was incorporated with the registered capital of Baht
100,000, divided into 1,000 ordinary shares, at the par
value of Baht 100 per share. The promoter including
Thames
Water International (Thailand) Co., Ltd., CH. Karnchang
Plc., CH. Karnchang Holding Co., Ltd., Berli Jucker Plc.,
Capital Rice Co., Ltd. and Bovis Limited. TMB Bank Plc.
and
Krung Thai Bank Plc. as lenders to PTW.
2nd August 1995 PTW increased its capital from originally Baht 100,000 to
Baht 200 million.
31st August 1995 PTW signed a Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) joint venture
agreement with PWA for a 25-year term commencing on the
first date of tap water distribution to PWA.
25th Dec. 1995 PTW increased its capital from originally Baht 200
million
to Baht 1,102 million.
15th October 1998 The first commercial operation date of PTW.
1st December 1998 PTW engaged Pathum Thani Operations Company Limited
("OPCO") to manage and maintain the Pathumthani-Rangsit
Water Supply Project under the Concession Agreement of
the
PWA. That is, OPCO shall manage the production of tap
water
in accordance with the specified volume so that PTW would
be able to distribute such tap water to the PWA. OPCO was
incorporated in November 1998, for operating its primary
business of management and maintenance of water
production
system in the "Pathumthani-Rangsit Water Supply Project"
for a period of 25 years, commencing from 1st December
(more)